On this page
- Watch: compare the work and parent support
- The differences to check first
- Look beyond the video-versus-books label
- Decide who will review the work
- Compare the package, not just the headline price
- Check the reading list and worldview
- A five-question preview worksheet
- Which should you preview first?
- Sources and limits
Start with RPC if you want to inspect a video-based course sequence. Start with Robinson if you want to inspect a routine built around printed reading, writing and math work. Then check who will help when the student gets stuck. These are starting points for a preview, not a claim that either program produces better results.
We have an affiliate relationship with Ron Paul Curriculum. All external links in this comparison are ordinary source links. We have not enrolled a child in either program or completed either paid curriculum. This article evaluates public descriptions, an RPC course outline and Robinson’s visible ordering options. Disclosure · Our review process.
Watch: compare the work and parent support
Watch on YouTube with English captions. Use the five-question preview note below to compare task, materials, help, feedback and access.
Original illustrations and AI-generated Elise narration. Public-source comparison, not a paid-course trial. Video added November 13, 2026.
The differences to check first
| Question | RPC | Robinson |
|---|---|---|
| What organizes the work? | Individual courses with video lessons and assignments. | A recurring math, writing, vocabulary and reading routine. |
| What material will we handle? | Online lessons and PDFs; inspect the specific course. | Printable materials; plan printing or suitable books. |
| What needs a separate check? | Parent feedback, course access and the chosen subject’s fit. | Math materials, printing needs and the exact online-access option. |
Sources: RPC overview and Robinson introduction.
Look beyond the video-versus-books label
RPC’s sixth-grade English outline combines literature, grammar and writing. It begins with an introduction, several Railway Children lessons and a review; later sections include essay assignments. The course overview says downloadable book PDFs are provided, with purchased or library copies as alternatives.
That is a concrete sequence to inspect, not evidence that a student can complete it without help. We verified the public outline and overview, not lesson playback. Do not treat this as an evaluation of the instructor’s delivery or the paid course.
Robinson’s introduction describes math checked against an answer key, a page of writing corrected by the parent, vocabulary work and reading. It describes Ray’s Arithmetic as included and recommends Saxon. Its base-package overview excludes Saxon books. This is the provider’s proposed routine, not a schedule we have tested with a family. Read the Robinson routine.
Decide who will review the work
RPC’s FAQ assigns essay grading to the parent when needed and allows math checking by the student or parent. It says RPC does not issue grades or track attendance. Course forums offer a route for questions; that does not establish guaranteed individual tutoring. RPC FAQ.
Robinson’s contents list describes book-linked examinations and answer keys, including advanced essay tests. An older questions page says there are no examinations. We would not call it test-free: the contents list documents assessments, while whether particular tests must be used remains unclear.
For either option, decide who will notice a weak explanation, review an unfinished assignment and help with a recurring error. If nobody can provide the support the learner needs, calling a curriculum independent does not fill that gap.
Compare the package, not just the headline price
RPC requires current household membership to access lessons. Its FAQ describes courses expiring one year after purchase, with extensions requested before expiry. Our RPC cost guide explains the household-plus-course calculation; confirm current provider totals before paying. Access terms.
On November 13, Robinson’s live order selector listed CDs with one or three years of RC Online, no-CD options with one or three years, and a separate SD-card/lifetime option. The page also describes distinct lifetime bundles, including a complete bundle listing Saxon. Printing supplies are separate. These are different purchase scopes, not interchangeable prices. Robinson ordering options.
The Robinson overview still mentions two included online years, while the live selector offers one or three. Use the selected option and obtain confirmation of any conflicting term before payment. We inspected option labels without adding anything to a cart; we did not verify a final checkout total or renewal transaction.
Make a full list: curriculum access, math books and answer keys, printing or binding, supplies, and any outside help you expect to use. Separate things you already own from new purchases. A larger bundle is not automatically better value for your family.
Check the reading list and worldview
RPC explicitly presents a limited-government and free-market perspective in its overview. Robinson’s contents list includes the King James Bible and historical texts. Inspect actual selections and how you would discuss them with the student. A program label is not a substitute for reviewing a history, literature or science course separately. We have not audited either complete curriculum for worldview or subject coverage.
A five-question preview worksheet
Use the same questions for both options. Write what you observed, what the provider describes and what remains unknown in separate notes.
- Task: What must the child actually produce?
- Materials: What must you open, print, borrow or buy?
- Help: Where can the child get another explanation?
- Feedback: Who checks the result, and what happens after an error?
- Access: What expires, renews or requires a separate purchase?
Worked example: a vague note becomes a useful plan
Fictional planning example, not a student result: “Can work independently” tells you little. Replace it with “Open the chosen reading assignment; write a short explanation; parent reviews the evidence in that explanation; save the work and note one question.” This is our suggested planning exercise, not an assignment copied from either program.
Now test the weak point: what if the student reads the material but cannot explain it? Mark “needs another explanation” and name the person or resource that can help. Do not mark the task understood just because the lesson is finished. The useful result is a specific support plan, even if it shows that neither option is a fit.
Print our broader curriculum decision worksheet to keep your comparison notes. It does not collect or submit student information.
Which should you preview first?
- RPC first: you want to examine a course sequence with video instruction and reading/writing assignments, and can arrange the feedback your child needs.
- Robinson first: you want to examine a book-and-writing routine and are prepared to organize materials and review written work.
- Keep looking: you need assured individual teaching, grading or support that the selected offering has not demonstrated. Ask about that service specifically before committing.
Try an appropriate sample in a comfortable subject and a difficult one. Record what helped and what remains untested. One successful session cannot establish long-term independence, learning gains or college readiness.
Sources and limits
Primary provider pages and visible Robinson option labels checked November 13, 2026. No purchase, paid-course trial, child participation, full lesson review or outcome measurement was performed. Access terms and package contents may change. This comparison deliberately does not rank programs, estimate parent hours or declare a universal winner.
Continue with the RPC sample-lesson guide, RPC review or RPC versus Time4Learning comparison if you need a different starting point.